Finance

Hearing could involve dueling mortgage plans – The Gazette


<!–Total Para: 1
Long Para:1
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The Trump administration’s still undisclosed plans to end the federal conservatorship of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will be a focus of upcoming confirmation hearings for the nominee of the federal agency overseeing the two government sponsored enterprises.

<!–Total Para: 2
Long Para:2
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Democrats such as Senate Banking ranking member Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio, have said they’re concerned about the suitability of Mark Calabria, the nominee to run the Federal Housing Finance Agency.

<!–Total Para: 3
Long Para:2
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The committee hasn’t said when it will hold a hearing on Calabria’s nomination.

<!–Total Para: 4
Long Para:3
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

“He comes out of the far right of the Republican Party,” Brown said on Tuesday. “They want to privatize everything, and my concern is what happens to the 30-year mortgage if they get their way?”

<!–Total Para: 5
Long Para:4
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The Senate Banking hearing could show the likely direction of efforts to overhaul agencies that are huge players in the national mortgage market.

<!–Total Para: 6
Long Para:5
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Not only could Calabria reveal administration thinking, he would be doing so in front of Senate Banking Chairman Michael D. Crapo, who last week released his own outline.

<!–Total Para: 7
Long Para:6
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Now chief economist for Vice President Mike Pence, Calabria once did research at the libertarian Cato Institute, where he said government-backed mortgages have done little to ensure the viability of 30-year fixed rate mortgages or boost homeownership rates that were no higher than they were before Fannie and Freddie grew to guarantee and securitize nearly half of all mortgages originated in the United States.

<!–Total Para: 8
Long Para:6
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

“He’s the only one that believes that, though,” Brown said.

<!–Total Para: 9
Long Para:7
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The government put Fannie and Freddie into conservatorship in 2008 in the wake of the housing market crash, spending $190 billion in the rescue.

<!–Total Para: 10
Long Para:8
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ADVERTISEMENT

The businesses have since returned about $292 billion to the Treasury in profit sweeps, but they remain on the hook for the original capital.

<!–Total Para: 11
Long Para:9
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Legislative proposals to end the conservatorship have come and gone in the past decade, but none has passed either chamber of Congress.

<!–Total Para: 12
Long Para:10
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Crapo, R-Idaho, outlined a proposal to privatize the two Government Sponsored Enterprises, requiring them to pay back the government, perhaps at a discount, and then recapitalize the companies so they could operate on their own.

<!–Total Para: 13
Long Para:11
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

His proposal differs from one he made in 2014 primarily in the privatization element. In his 2014 plan, proposed along with Democratic Sen. Tim Johnson, he would have wound them down.

<!–Total Para: 14
Long Para:12
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The privatization provision makes the plan more palpable to Fannie and Freddie shareholders, but does little to satisfy other constituencies that opposed the 2014 bill.

<!–Total Para: 15
Long Para:13
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Crucially, the Crapo proposal would preserve government backing for 30-year fixed rate mortgages, a feature that many say is essential to the housing industry.

<!–Total Para: 16
Long Para:14
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The proposal would convert Fannie and Freddie into private mortgage guarantors competing with other private businesses.

<!–Total Para: 17
Long Para:15
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

But the loans they back would be eligible for bundling into mortgage backed securities by Ginnie Mae, a government-sponsored enterprise that would have an implicit government guarantee.

<!–Total Para: 18
Long Para:16
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ADVERTISEMENT

<!–

–>

Thank you for signing up for our e-newsletter!

You should start receiving the e-newsletters within a couple days.

Crapo’s outline would direct Ginnie Mae to also establish a mortgage insurance fund that the guarantors would pay insurance premiums into.

<!–Total Para: 19
Long Para:17
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

As he did in 2014, Crapo is calling for a 10 basis point annual assessment on all mortgages in the scheme and funnel it to the Housing Trust Fund, the Capital Magnet Fund and a new Market Access Fund, which would replace Fannie and Freddie’s existing affordable housing goals and duty-to-serve requirements.

<!–Total Para: 20
Long Para:17
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The panel reported the 2014 bill to the full Senate favorably, but no floor vote followed.

<!–Total Para: 21
Long Para:18
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Jon Tester of Montana and Mark Warner of Virginia are the only two Democrats still on the committee of the six who backed the 2014 bill. Brown, Robert Menendez, D-N.J., and Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., who are still on the committee, voted against the 2014 bill.

Industry Support

As it did in 2014, the housing industry has cautiously supported Crapo.

<!–Total Para: 22
Long Para:19
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The Mortgage Bankers Association released a statement calling the outline “a significant sign of his continued commitment to work toward finally ending the conservatorships of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and ensuring a stable and liquid market — with an explicit, paid-for government guarantee — for both single-family and multifamily mortgages.”

<!–Total Para: 23
Long Para:20
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The National Association of Home Builders described it as an “important step to move the debate forward.”

<!–Total Para: 24
Long Para:21
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Credit unions applauded the effort, noting that the outline would prohibit guarantors from offering volume-based discounts on the fees they charge.

<!–Total Para: 25
Long Para:22
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The smaller institutions have called the industry practice of offering better terms for bigger loan packages unfair.

<!–Total Para: 26
Long Para:23
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The National Association of Federal Credit Unions and the Credit Union National Association were both more tepid in their support back in 2014.

<!–Total Para: 27
Long Para:23
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Consumer and civil rights advocates are opposed.

<!–Total Para: 28
Long Para:24
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ADVERTISEMENT

The Center for Responsible Lending, the NAACP, the National Urban League and a half-dozen other organizations said, “it is disappointing to see a proposal that weakens the regulatory authority over the GSEs and returns the Federal Housing Finance Agency, Fannie and Freddie’s regulator, to the same frail status the regulator was in leading to the housing crash of 2008 that hurt so many hardworking families and significantly contributed to the current lagging rates of Black and Latino homeownership in the country.”

<!–Total Para: 29
Long Para:24
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Crapo also can expect opposition on his right flank.

<!–Total Para: 30
Long Para:25
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The Heritage Foundation released a proposal last week rejecting any overhaul that would retain government guarantees and calling for the Trump administration to move without Congress to shrink the footprint of Fannie and Freddie.

<!–Total Para: 31
Long Para:25
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The proposal echoes Calabria from his time at Cato.

<!–Total Para: 32
Long Para:26
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Investor Constituency Crapo’s outline seems to have flipped Fannie and Freddie’s shareholders to his side. His proposal in 2014, which would have wiped out equity holders, led shares to plunge by nearly a third.

<!–Total Para: 33
Long Para:27
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The outline he released last week led to a small decline in prices that have more than doubled since Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin and acting FHFA director Joseph Otting started talking in recent weeks about moving the GSEs out of conservatorship without Congress.

<!–Total Para: 34
Long Para:27
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Otting also is the director of the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency.

<!–Total Para: 35
Long Para:28
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

“I’m concerned about the administration’s involvement,” Brown said. “We don’t know what the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency is doing.”

<!–Total Para: 36
Long Para:29
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Brown said Democrats might dig in their heels further if the administration tries to spur Congress to act by threatening to go it alone.

<!–Total Para: 37
Long Para:30
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

“We hear there’s a plan — an administration plan — and we want to see it before we got into this (Crapo’s proposal), so we can go in with eyes wide open,” Brown added.

<!–Total Para: 38
Long Para:31
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Brown, along with House Financial Services Chairwoman Maxine Waters, D-Calif., asked Otting in a letter to provide more details on the administration’s ideas for Fannie and Freddie.

<!–Total Para: 39
Long Para:31
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

In response, Otting only provided a cursory description of the FHFA and its statutory duties.

<!–Total Para: 40
Long Para:31
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

Crapo told CQ that he wants to work with the administration.

<!–Total Para: 41
Long Para:32
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ADVERTISEMENT

“I believe that the administration, generally at the leadership level, would like to move ahead with Congress and work jointly, and that’s what I think is the best outcome,” Crapo said.

<!–Total Para: 42
Long Para:33
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

“If Congress once again gets stuck, I could see the administration seeing if they could do some of the kinds of preparatory work for a congressional solution.”

<!–Total Para: 43
Long Para:34
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

The administration ultimately may decide against moving forward with any plan that could rattle an already shaky housing market just before the 2020 elections.

<!–Total Para: 44
Long Para:34
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

But Brown doesn’t think that’ll stop them.

<!–Total Para: 45
Long Para:35
Long Pra Total: 35
Total Para Total: 45
–>

“Do you read what the White House tweets out every day?” Brown, a potential presidential candidate, said. “It’s closing the government down, it’s a tax bill that screws the middle class, it’s regulations that weaken protections for workers. So, why would housing be any different?”

Give us feedback

We value your trust and work hard to provide fair, accurate coverage. If you have found an error or omission in our reporting, tell us here.

Or if you have a story idea we should look into? Tell us here.

Let’s block ads! (Why?)



Source link

LEAVE A COMMENT